So its rare to get a chance to look at any data related to fic genres in fandoms.]. I 've done a number of posts on SPN fic, both fandom wide and in the
spn_j2_bigbang, most recently on
this year's challengeAnyway I found today that a Merlin Big Bang -
paperlegends had just posted the fic summaries for art claiming in their Big Bang. Same warning as with my other posts - these stats relate only to this challenge and should not be assumed to be reflective of genre representations in fic writing overall in the fandom.
Anyway - the stats! These fic are all Merlin fic ie no RPF.(I found an RPF BB
merlinbb_rpf but last year it had only 6 entries - that can't be right surely?! is there another one?)
As a reminder, in the SPN fics in this year's Big Bang there were 87 fics with a breakdown of 75% slash, 20% Gen and 5% het. Note while there 14 other Big Bangs in SPN, these ratios have been reasonably steady over the six years of the Big Bang, with the main change being a slight increase in slash since 2010 due to the arrival of Destiel.
Anyway - over in Camelot there were 62 fic summaries posted. 82% (or 51 fics with three of these were femmeslash) were slash and 5% (3 fics) were het. Of most interest, no fics were labelled as Gen although one was labelled as "not shippy per se" and another as "really pre-slash".
There were 6 fics or 10% that listed an equal number of slash and het pairings. A number of the fics that were - judging from the summaries primarily slash fics - also listed het pairings. No vagina warnings here!
The other things that I noticed was the amount of fics that warned for character deaths - 20 fics or just over 30% !!! You Merlin fans are hardcore! Or maybe in SPN we suffer enough through characters dying in canon that we avoid it in fic?
Finally warnings - generally very srs bsns although I did like "Death by Mythical Creatures, Destruction of Landmarks" and "fire-fighting and car accidents and cats trapped in trees"
And the interesting juxtaposition of "Character death, violence, betrayal, so much fluff you'll want to puke". Wow in SPN we define fluff as Sam and Dean making cupcakes and playing with kittens. It doesn't usually come alongside death, gore and betrayal!
Anyway some hypothesis...certainly as I've stated before I have the impression that SPN on LJ has a high proportion of Gen due to the only pairing being available for the first 3 seasons was Wincest. Merlin obviously has a number of canonical het pairings, as potential slash pairings which has led to shipping dominating, at least in this challenge.
of course this is a very high level look but I am fascinated,. I'd love to hear any insights from those of you that write or read across any fandom.